And What To Say Instead
We say “death tax” instead of what it really is: an “inheritance income tax.” Two little words, “death panels,” were capable of nearly derailing health insurance reform, even though it was a Republican idea that conforms to many conservative ideologies, largest among them, personal responsibility. Harvard-educated President Obama is considered “elite,” while Yale-educated George W. Bush is considered “down home.”
Many Democrats buy into the old saw that the Democratic party has had a history of "tax and spend" policies that needs to change or be lived down somehow. Until the Occupy movement brought the topic front and center, even most Democrats accepted the notion that businesses were "job creators" and worried more about distracting the opposition from this "fact" than debunking it for the deception it actually is.
Unfortunately, Democrats have failed to define language strong enough to rebut Republicans who have defined who we are and what we want, with falsehoods and fabrications.
HOW TO TALK LIKE A REPUBLICAN
Professional media strategist Frank Luntz has been providing Republicans with a detailed handbook on exactly what language to use and not to use for decades. He has built up a lexicon that is not only far-reaching and deeply ingrained, but also very, very successful. As Progressive Democratic linguist George Lakoff explains it, this "framing" is crucial to how they've managed to win so much of the debate.
Here are some examples from Luntz's handbooks, of how the Republican party has been taught to frame the way they talk:
Don't say "bonus!"
Luntz advised that if [corporations] give their employees an income boost during the holiday season, they should never refer to it as a "bonus." "If you give out a bonus at a time of financial hardship, you're going to make people angry. It's 'pay for performance.'"
Don't say that the government "taxes the rich."
Instead, tell [people] that the government "takes from the rich."
"If you talk about raising taxes on the rich," the public responds favorably, Luntz cautioned. But "if you talk about government taking the money from hardworking Americans, the public says no."
This sleight-of-tongue has managed to manipulate at least half the country into believing things that simply are not true. And this type of language mash-up has been so successfully drilled into the vernacular, that Democrats have been hard-pressed to come up with a simple and just-as-effective way to expose the lies beneath them.
DEMOCRATS NEED A HANDBOOK OF OUR OWN
How can Democrats and Progressives fix this? Start by never saying any of the following five words or phrases again.
1. Never say Entitlements.
Instead, say Earned Benefits.
While the word "entitlement" was originally coined as a way to illustrate that the receiver of the benefits was entitled to them by having worked to earn them, or having been taxed to support them, it has been re-defined by the right as akin to a spoiled child who acts as if they're "entitled" even though they are not.
"Earned benefits," on the other hand, cannot be twisted or misconstrued to mean anything other than what they are: something the recipient has actually earned, as opposed to something they are being given. Social Security and Medicare are paid into through taxes deducted from employees' paychecks, or the paychecks of one's spouse or parent. No one who hasn't either personally paid into these programs, or been the spouse or child of someone who has paid into these programs, or, in the case of Medicare Part B, paid a monthly premium in order to receive them, can extract benefits from these programs.
Here is a perfect example of how the right wing uses the word "entitled" as a pejorative associated with Democrats (emphasis mine):
"Fluke is an entitled liberal, which is both emblematically typical and essentially required for one to be a liberal in today's American political landscape ... Her talking points represent a very real attitude quickly manifesting itself into mainstream American thought process: that a person literally deserves the resources of another. This, of course, is the entitlement and dependency culture on which the Democratic Party has rallied around, encouraged, campaigned, and insisted." ~ Rush Limbaugh
Shame on Rush Limbaugh. Democrats have done nothing of the sort. Recall that the subject Ms. Fluke was testifying about is insured individuals. That means that they have paid into the pool in order to be able to take resources out later when needed. Even if the check was dispersed by their employer, it's still their benefit as employees, paid out in the form of insurance coverage in lieu of cash compensation.
Not to mention any shared responsibility the employee, or in Sandra Fluke's case, the student, may have in paying the monthly premium. (For the record, students at Georgetown University where Sandra Fluke was a student, pay 100 percent of their own premium toward their student health insurance.)
Do not allow the right wing to frame this issue in their terms. These are Earned Benefits. Say that.
2. Never say Redistribution of Wealth.
Instead, say Fair Wages For Work.
When we hear "redistribution," we think in terms of simply moving things around, not something earned by someone. And when you tack the word "wealth" onto it, everybody's hackles immediately go up. "What do you mean, redistribute my wealth? You don't get to take something from me and give it to someone else! I work hard for what I get; let other people work for their own money, not mine!"
But when we hear "fair wages for work," we know instantly that we are talking about paying working people a fair wage for the work they're doing, not giving them something they haven't actually earned.
Since at least 1965, Republican policies have created a corporate culture that only rewards those at the very, very, very top of the pyramid. While the average "hourly wage" equivalent for CEOs has gone from $490.31 to $5,419.97 (that’s over $11 million a year), the average hourly wage for workers has stagnated at $19.71 — just $40,997.00 per year. The same $40,997.00 that we were earning in 1965. At 2012 inflation. We deserve fair wages for our work in today's dollars. Say that.
3. Never say Employer Paid Health Insurance.
Instead, say Employee-Earned Health Insurance.
When we say "employer paid," we immediately think of it as something that's given to the employee by their employer. But as I pointed out in my blog post, "It's Not About Who Writes The Check—Stop The Republican Lie About Who Pays For Contraceptives," all employee health insurance is earned by virtue of the employee's labor. That makes it "paid for" by the employee, even if they aren't the ones writing the checks to the insurance companies themselves. Employee health insurance is just one of several forms of compensation in exchange for work that include cash, retirement funds, long- and short-term disability coverage, etc.
Employee health insurance is not a "gift," it is compensation in exchange for work. Cease the work and the compensation ceases right along with it. Employees earn their insurance. Say that.
4. Never say Government Spending.
Instead, call it Taxpayer Investment in America.
When we hear "spending," we automatically think of going shopping and whipping out the credit card. And while government at every level often leverages their ability to borrow at low interest rates to fund their spending, it's hardly the same thing as going out and buying a dress you're only going to wear once and then hanging in the closet until it's out of style, or a set of golf clubs that will collect more cobwebs than it will birdies.
What governments actually do is invest in our cities, states, country and our people. Government invests in infrastructure that affords us the ability to move around freely. It invests in programs that train people with job skills. It invests in research that cures diseases. There is an actual benefit to "spending" when a government does it, which actually makes it an investment in all our futures.
And who is "the government"? We The People. It's a Constitutional phrase that evokes strong support for whatever follows. Democrats need to take Constitutional language back from the Republican party and make it ours again, since Democratic principles of equality and liberty were the driving forces behind the creation of this great nation in the first place.
We are investing in our future.
Say it this way. Every time.
5. Never say Corporate America.
Instead, refer to them as Unelected Corporate Government.
Calling businesses "Corporate America" gives the impression that somehow corporations are the same as human Americans. But in spite of what the current Supreme Court would have you believe, they aren't.
In fact, in many ways in our daily lives, we are governed far more by corporations than we are by governments. Corporations govern where we shop, what we pay for goods and services, who gets access and who doesn't, how we communicate and what we pay for that privilege, and so on.
But more importantly, Corporations govern us by buying our legislators to do their bidding with campaign donations, and by actually writing legislation that makes it into our law books. Corporations govern when they privatize formerly-public, taxpayer-funded institutions, like schools, prisons and military operations. And unlike actual governments, they do it solely for their benefit and profits, not those of actual Americans.
And if there's one thing we know the right wing zealots claim not to like the most, it's "government interference in our lives." So what could be worse than the government we actually elect to make our laws "interfering in our lives"? It's a government structure that we didn't even elect interfering in our lives!
Corporations are not "Corporate America," they are Unelected Corporate Governors ruling over us with their lobbyists and ALEC members. Describe them that way and people will come to resent their presence in our public policy-making.
Turning once again to Professor Lakoff, "Unfortunately, Luntz is still ahead of most progressives responding to him. Progressives need to learn how framing works. Bashing Luntz, bashing Fox News, bashing the right-wing pundits and leaders using their frames and arguing against their positions just keeps their frames in play. ... Progressives have magnificent stories of their own to tell. They need to be telling them nonstop. Let's lure the right into using OUR frames in public discourse."
Let's start doing that by chaging the way we frame the above five concepts when we talk to our friends, neighbors, and colleagues, or when we're interacting with people online about our political views. The more we repeat the progressive frames: Earned Benefits, Fair Wages for Work, Employee-Earned Health Insurance, Taxpayer Investment in America, and Unelected Corporate Government, the more "mainstream" those terms will become. And the more mainstream they become, the more they'll be accepted as truisms (which they legitimately are). And when the populace accepts the truth that programs people pay into, such as Social Security and Medicare, are earned benefits, the easier it will be to get good legislation written to protect them, and the harder it will become for the right to convince people they ought to be destroyed.
Let's work together to build the country we believe in!